top of page

Welcome to the archive

Mister Pizza in Mayfield, NY, served homemade pizza, pasta, and dining-room favorites for decades at 7 North School Street. Browse the menu pages for reference, read the full story on About, and see the owners’ thank-you in the footer after our closing on September 13, 2025.

New readers can open the Mayfield archival site guide for a short tour of this static archive, links back to the homepage, and where menus, About, and contact still live.

Pizza photo linking to the pizza menu
Pizza

Wood-fired style pies and slices when we were open

Pasta photo linking to the pasta dinners menu
Pasta

Slow-simmered sauces behind the recipes

Dining room photo linking to the dining page
Dining

Dining-room specials on select nights

Mister Pizza Notice

​

As many of you know, we have been talking about and anticipating retirement for some time and after 28 wonderful years here, owning and operating Mister Pizza, we will be moving on to the next stage of life and will be closing September 13, 2025.


When we began in the restaurant business 35 years ago opening our first restaurant, we could never have imagined all the great people we'd meet and life long friends we would make. We began and grew our family during this time, with our boys playing huge parts in the business, being instrumental in the success of Mister Pizza over these 28 years. We are looking forward to spending time with our family, especially our four wonderful grandchildren, and with friends. We are very grateful for the support everyone has shown us through these years -our customers, our family and our "Mister Pizza" family (past and present)-

we will cherish the memories and laughs we've shared.


Our Last Day Open Will Be Saturday, September 13.

 

Anyone with a gift certificate, please use before 9/13.

Much Thanks and Love to You All-Chris & Sandra

​

​​

​Place Your

ORDER NOW​

1 518 661 5599

Subscribe Below To Receive Our Newsletters

Congrats! You’re subscribed

Prices Shown Do Not Include Tax and May Change Without Notice

Contact Us

© 2020 MayfieldMisterPizza.com created by Vincent Ferlazzo

    bottom of page