top of page


Serving Mayfield NY With Great Food Since 1997!

Welcome to Mister Pizza, your local family pizzeria. Where we are dedicated to giving you the very best food and service possible. Call or stop in today and we’ll be happy to serve you!


Founded in 1997 by Christopher Ward, Mister Pizza has come a long way from its beginnings. We first opened in 1997 on the corner of Rt. 30 & School Street, across from the Stewarts. With family recipes and a love for fine Italian cuisine, Christopher Ward & his family set out to serve Mayfield with great food and exceptional service. Over time we grew as a business, gaining many wonderful friends and customers along the way. With the desire to provide more for our customers, we wanted to increase our menu size and also provide a dining area that was unique & family friendly. With size restraints an issue we decided to move shop. After many months of construction and renovations, we reopened at our new location in the fall of 2009, located at 7 North School Street. Now with a larger kitchen and a sit down dining area, we can offer a diverse menu for our take out & dining customers. None of this could have been accomplished without the on-going business & support we receive from our loyal customers. Mister Pizza customers are the best!


Take-out or Delivery

Take-out or delivery is available four days a week during our business hours. You can find our take-out menu by clicking here. We do deliver in Mayfield. Our radius is around 5 miles from our location. Walk-in orders are very welcomed.



Our sit down dining is also available four nights a week. However we stop seating customers a half hour before closing. You can order anything on the take-out menu in the dining room. There are also weekly dining specials available. We serve beer & wine in the dining room only. Must be 21 or over to order any alcoholic beverage. Be prepared to present your I.D. if ordering any alcoholic beverage. If you have any questions regarding the dining room please contact us.


We do have gift cards available at the shop. They make great presents for anyone and can be used for take-out or dining. There is NO fee to purchase!


If you ever have any questions about our products or services please don’t hesitate to contact us. The best way to reach us is to call us during business hours. However you can email us anytime or try our Facebook page.


Thank you for all of your continued support.

          -The Mister Pizza Crew

bottom of page